The last thing I need to choose for the basement half-bath is shelving. I just want a place to put some pretty odds and ends on the wall opposite the sink and toilet. I like these three choices:
Remember, this is what I’m already working with for the rest of the room:
Which option would you choose?
96 comments
Minneapolis Apartments
Love #3 but not in the context of your bathroom… This is an older post so I can see into the future.. ;)
Amanda
I’m voting #1 because I have two of those. They both currently are hanging in my kitchen.
I love them! They get a lot of compliments because they are so interesting in person. They’re pretty sturdy, as well. I currently am displaying all white knick-knacks in them, but in our old apartment I used them for DVDs and other things. They’re pretty versatile.
Art
No.1 would be better for storage, but since you say this is for display, I also pick #3.
Amelia
I think I’d do #3 in buttercup to match other accessories!
Tyla B
No. 1 is too college dorm-ish for me. I like 3 if you were going to work it into a niche. So I guess I’ll go with 2, since it is the least imposing, but it doesn’t look like it will hold much – which may be what you are going for. I’m not much help am I? I think the bathroom is going to be be-a-utiful!
S. Shaw
I like #2.
Kimbydee
#1 looks vintage and quirky both. Love it!
Ashley
I think either 2 or 3, the first one looks like something that would go in your utility closet.
Parakh
I initially thought #3 – but then considering what you have already chosen I would go with #2 – it think it would fit nicely and bring attention to your knick nacks and not so much the shelves
Natalie
#3 ~ I love the clean lines and modern feel. It seems like it would go best with the rest of the plan. Can’t wait to see it all come together! :)
AK
not #1
melinda KE
I would use the Ekby Valter brackets and Ekby Järpen shelves, maybe two or three of them, with some nice baskets. I also like #2 if you have enough floor room. I can’t wait to see the room all put together!
Janine
my first choice would be #3, with #2 coming in second.
Katie
Go for #3…
Katie
#3. :)
alison
I love number 1. Just do.
Allison
I like three the best on it’s own, but I think two works the best with the style of the space.
ashleyD
i vote for 3!!
Amanda
Three! I like the clean lines and there’s a lot of space between the shelves to stack high or have space there. And you’ll have more control compared to number one as there’s not a lot of control over where to put the items as they’re in “boxes”
christy
when will we see the new baby’s nursery? Did I miss it?
Mandi
I think #2, it floats some negative (wall) space between layers and I think that is very important in such a small space. The other shelves are too busy for that area. Besides, you won’t need to put much down there – a couple decorative items, a spare set of hand towels . . . that’s it.
WES
I like #3 for the bathroom, and I don’t think you necessarily need to get it in white. I think the black could look really nice as a contrast to the white of the toilet and sink.
#1 is nice for general storage in either a basement or a playroom but I don’t think it fits with your bathroom even if it is in the basement.
Lisa
I vote 2 or 3. 1 looks too much like high school locker accessories to me. The solid shelf will look better with pretty things, I think.
Julie Anne
Of the choices you have, I like 2. My friend used them in her kitchen recently, and I wasn’t sure until I saw them up.
Have you thought of something vintage-y looking to coordinate with your vitage plumbing and lighting fixtures? This Polder shelf and towel rack combo would be useful and space-appropriate:
http://www.polder.com/80-05.html
Renee Nordholm
I also vote for #3
Kirsten
My personal favorite is #1, but it’s too industrial for your space, and #2 while budget friendly, will probably look too cheap in your space. So my vote is for #3.
Rachel H.
Number THREE!!!
Robin
We are all in love with west elm these days!! I can’t get enough ;)
Tracy
I vote for #3.
Dianna
I vote for 3 also, although I have a soft spot for 1 because i have it in my dining room & love it. any of these choices will look great!
lori
three three three!
meryl rose
Number 3. The first looks like it belongs more in a garage, and the second just isn’t fun enough for you.
Emily Stearley
One. I think the style of it is a nice contrast from the rest of the room. Plus, I like the “cubby” look for displaying fun things.
reb
2 for me!
Brittany
#3. I love a good wall-mounted shelf and this one is clean and simple.
heartartz
sorry…link does not work
It should have gone to
West Elm – Tall Industrial Metal Bath Cabinet
heartartz
oops
her is 1st link again:
http://www.westelm.com/products/tall-industrial-metal-bath-cabinet-g286/?pkey=e|meatl%2Bindustrial|3|best|0|1|24||2&cm_src=PRODUCTSEARCH||NoFacet-_-NoFacet-_-Common%20Top%20Wide%20Rule%20Free%20Shipping-_-
heartartz
This is so cool
http://www.westelm.com/products/tall-industrial-metal-bath-cabinet-g286/?pkey=e|meatl%2Bindustrial|3|best|0|1|24||2&cm_src=PRODUCTSEARCH||NoFacet-_-NoFacet-_-Common%20Top%20Wide%20Rule%20Free%20Shipping-_-
and so is this
http://stores.homestead.com/hudsongoods/-strse-1632/industrial-perforated-metal-shelf/Detail.bok
Anya
Definitely #3.
I’m looking forward to seeing it all done! :D
Ingrid Hames
I don’t like 1, it reminds me too much of milk crates from the grocery. I think I like 3 the best, simple and stylish.. :)
Eileen
3
Erika
Three!
Valerie
My vote is for #3. #1 could maybe work if you spray painted it white…
samsonizzle
My initial choice was #2. After being temporarily wooed by the West Elm photos, my senses returned to me and I realized you will be getting much the same look with the Ikea shelves, and you cannot beat the price. Your cute accessories will draw the most attention; I don’t think it’s necessary to splurge on what they’ll be sitting on.
Lila Ferraro
Personally, I like one and three because they’ll give you the biggest storage option. But, three may look the best!
xoxo
Lila Ferraro
Jessica at Lavender and Lilies
#3 is my fave. I have thought about that for my house too.
Rebecca @ beautiful square feet
Running the risk of going against the popular vote here, I really like number 1! It’s really funky, and I really like the juxtaposition of the industrial shelving versus your pretty Athro hooks.
Sanja
I’d go with #1 to get a nice texture along with the shelving. It somewhat mimics the geometric shape of the tiles and adds more interest than the other two.
Sarah Jane
I love the wire shelving, but the other two seem to fit the classiness of the bathroom better.
Joy
I really like #3!
Jen
Even though I love the wire racks, I’d vote for #2!
Keeps it simple.
dana
#2!!
Heather
#3, all the way.
Nicole S.
I actually like #1 the best. It is a far more interesting shelf, adds some texture and contrast.
Meredith
Option 1 will be horrible to dust and as bathrooms seem to attract ridiculous amounts of dust that will be a problem down the line. I love 3. I think it adds visual interest and great clean lines!
Jen K
I like 2 or 3 : )
Jana
I vote #2 so that the shelf itself does not distract from your pretty little knick knacks
Patty
Definitely No. 3. What a pretty bathroom this will be!
chelsea
OOo, I’m a fan of the first!
RD
#3–I think this works best with your existing look. Beautiful bath!
Kelsey
#1 is super cute, but I’m not sure about introducing another metal into such a small space. As such, I’d go with #3.
Bre
Option 3. I do like the idea of something done in wire or metal, just not that particular 9 cubby shelf.
Nina
Personally I like number 1 the best….but, I think with the rest of the things you have chosen that number 3 would look the best in your bathroom. Can’t wait to hear which one you pick!
Melissa
I really like option number 1!!
Jessie
#3 :]
Jess
Erin
I vote #2! I think #1 is too industrial and #3 might be too modern. #2 is just right. But really, I bet any one of them would look lovely in the bathroom.
Megan
If I had to choose, I would go with number 2.
What about this?
http://www.wisteria.com/Wire-Basket-Wall-Shelves-with-Hooks/productinfo/W5178/
Caitlin
I vote for #3! I like how the linear lines of the shelves play off of the stripes in the cup, the towel and the sconce :)
Brandi H.
I like #2. But, #2 and #3 are very similar and I think would look nice. I don’t think #1 looks very functional or pleasing to the eye.
PAppel
Love, love, love #1 but don’t feel it would fit in with the rest of the items in the room. #2 and #3 would fit in nicely; however, all three have finishes that appear to be too dark for your bathroom’s palette. Are you planning on changing the finish on them? That might influence decision.
Making it Lovely
The design board is a little misleading, because the tile has dark gray (almost black) grout. I also found slightly different towels that have more black in them (from west elm, but they’re not on the site yet), so the black shelving will work well in the space.
Amanda
#1 from CB2!
Misty
My vote is for #3. I think it is classy.
Laura
I vote for #2!
Annie H
I hate to say this, but I don’t like any of them. Looking at your mood board all the shelves you selected seem out of place. It looks they would be the darkest thing in the room. Almost the focal point. Sorry.
julie s
If I were choosing, number 3 would be my pick!
Alisa (mrsbcs)
I am familiar with the #2 shelves and really like them so I vote for #2.
MaNai
I like option 3 based on the other items you already have in the space.
Kathy
I love option 3. Option 2 would work as well, but I like the unified look of 3. Option 1 seems a bit much.
Cheryl
#2 is simpler, would keep clutter controlled. #3 would give you more room to play with and depending on the dimensions might be nice for a few rolled face towels/washcloths and decorative items, as long as the depth of the shelves isn’t too much. #1 says ‘too busy’ for me. I see form and function in #2, less so in #1 (but still enough), and none in #1 for a bathroom, particularly.
Danielle
2! I think the shelf should be simple for your knick knacks to stand out.
Kim
I don’t care for #1 with the rest of the space, but the either of other options would be lovely.
heartartz
I like 1 and 3
But I picture something like this…or even a thrifted painted piece in black
http://www.homedecorators.com/P/Salem_42W_Four_Shelf_Bookcase_with_Glass_Doors/120/
Michelle
I like #3.
Jamie @ Happy House, Happy Home
Definitely #3! Loooove it!
If you went with #2, would you do more than 1?
And I agree that #1 looks too industrial and doesnt fit with your bathroom.
Making it Lovely
If I go with #2, I’d do two or three shelves.
Rebecca
#3
Jen Decker
i vote for 3!
Chroma Lab
I vote #2. It’s going to come together beautifully!
Martha
I think #3 goes best with the room. I love #1 but it might be distracting…
shelley
2 or 3 are my favorites. I think #1 seems too overpowering.
Anne @ It's a Baltimore Life
I like #2. I think #1 is too industrial and #3 is too modern for the space!
Cristina
I think options #2 and #3 go best with your current theme. #1 seems out of place, like it belongs in either an office room, closet, or garage. So, if you have a LOT of odds and ends, go with #3. Otherwise, go with #2 for smaller odds and ends.
Taz
I think option 3 fits best with the rest of the room…
coasterkim
I think I don’t love the casual wire rack with the fancy gold mirror and towel hook. I think either #2 or #3 would look great, but I think #3 is my favorite.
Comments are closed.